diff --git a/server/controllers/ShareController.js b/server/controllers/ShareController.js
index 3022cb7f..0770bfa4 100644
--- a/server/controllers/ShareController.js
+++ b/server/controllers/ShareController.js
@@ -42,19 +42,14 @@ class ShareController {
       const playbackSession = ShareManager.findPlaybackSessionBySessionId(req.cookies.share_session_id)
 
       if (playbackSession) {
-        const playbackSessionMediaItemShare = ShareManager.findByMediaItemId(playbackSession.mediaItemId)
-        if (!playbackSessionMediaItemShare) {
-          Logger.error(`[ShareController] Share playback session ${req.cookies.share_session_id} media item share not found with id ${playbackSession.mediaItemId}`)
-          return res.sendStatus(500)
-        }
-        if (playbackSessionMediaItemShare.slug === slug) {
+        if (mediaItemShare.id === playbackSession.mediaItemShareId) {
           Logger.debug(`[ShareController] Found share playback session ${req.cookies.share_session_id}`)
           mediaItemShare.playbackSession = playbackSession.toJSONForClient()
           return res.json(mediaItemShare)
         } else {
-          // TODO: Close old session and use same session id
-          Logger.info(`[ShareController] Share playback session found with id ${req.cookies.share_session_id} but media item share slug ${playbackSessionMediaItemShare.slug} does not match requested slug ${slug}`)
-          res.clearCookie('share_session_id')
+          // Changed media item share - close other session
+          Logger.debug(`[ShareController] Other playback session is already open for share session. Closing session "${playbackSession.displayTitle}"`)
+          ShareManager.closeSharePlaybackSession(playbackSession)
         }
       } else {
         Logger.info(`[ShareController] Share playback session not found with id ${req.cookies.share_session_id}`)
diff --git a/server/managers/ShareManager.js b/server/managers/ShareManager.js
index da3b6fc5..f6827973 100644
--- a/server/managers/ShareManager.js
+++ b/server/managers/ShareManager.js
@@ -25,10 +25,19 @@ class ShareManager {
    * @param {import('../objects/PlaybackSession')} playbackSession
    */
   addOpenSharePlaybackSession(playbackSession) {
-    Logger.info(`[ShareManager] Adding new open share playback session ${playbackSession.shareSessionId}`)
+    Logger.info(`[ShareManager] Adding new open share playback session "${playbackSession.displayTitle}"`)
     this.openSharePlaybackSessions.push(playbackSession)
   }
 
+  /**
+   *
+   * @param {import('../objects/PlaybackSession')} playbackSession
+   */
+  closeSharePlaybackSession(playbackSession) {
+    Logger.info(`[ShareManager] Closing share playback session "${playbackSession.displayTitle}"`)
+    this.openSharePlaybackSessions = this.openSharePlaybackSessions.filter((s) => s.id !== playbackSession.id)
+  }
+
   /**
    * Find an open media item share by media item ID
    * @param {string} mediaItemId
diff --git a/server/models/LibraryItem.js b/server/models/LibraryItem.js
index cffcb80a..098eacdf 100644
--- a/server/models/LibraryItem.js
+++ b/server/models/LibraryItem.js
@@ -568,7 +568,6 @@ class LibraryItem extends Model {
           oldLibraryItem.numEpisodesIncomplete = li.numEpisodesIncomplete
         }
         if (li.mediaType === 'book' && options.include?.includes?.('share')) {
-          console.log('Lookup share for media item id', li.mediaId)
           oldLibraryItem.mediaItemShare = ShareManager.findByMediaItemId(li.mediaId)
         }